My view to YC is more similar with yours than the OP’s actually.
The red flag I saw is: they basically encourage every one to apply, no matter the stages, areas, backgrounds, etc. Their PR seems saying everyone could have a chance as long as you dream big. But TBH I doubt it would the reality.
The lack of a thesis and target audience feels like more an exclusive club game. The selectiveness is part the product, leading to better chances to get following funding and talents. Ofc nothing wrong with it, but I think people should have a realistic view to it.
I have seen successful YC founders not get in with their next companies. There's a lot of competing applications. Getting in is not easy. But I don't believe it's a club. I have evidence that suggests the opposite.
People need to stop conjuring up evil YC processes just to reassure themselves about not applying. It's fine not to apply! But if you're rationalizing it, consider that maybe you really do want to, and are just scared of rejection? That's normal too.
The red flag I saw is: they basically encourage every one to apply, no matter the stages, areas, backgrounds, etc. Their PR seems saying everyone could have a chance as long as you dream big. But TBH I doubt it would the reality.
The lack of a thesis and target audience feels like more an exclusive club game. The selectiveness is part the product, leading to better chances to get following funding and talents. Ofc nothing wrong with it, but I think people should have a realistic view to it.