Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

Lots of people will argue against the GPL on philosophical grounds alone.

I'm going to argue against it based on its ambiguity. Just reading this thread illustrates the problem clearly. In the old days of simple, standalone applications and libraries on a single machine, the obligations of the recipient of the source code was clear: your own code must also be GPL compatibile. With this new model of some of the code existing on the server and some on the client, and the GPL's use of the term "derivative work," it's very unclear to the average programmer what his or her obligations under the license are. Ultimately you as the copyright holder have to enforce your license, and the ambiguity in the meaning of the license, your motivation for choosing the license, and your intentions make things muddled.

If you are simply looking for a "copyleft" license in which people must contribute changes to Meteor back, that's fine, but the LGPL or MPL are probably better license choices.

If you want to ensure that your project is only used for open source applications with case-by-case commercial licensing exceptions, that's fine, but the AGPL is a better license choice.

I whole-heartedly agree with all of that.

As soon as there is ambiguity there is also legal risk, and attorneys tend to recommend a conservative position. The only way to avoid such ambiguity is to limit yourself to the well proven "crystal clear" GPL use cases. As has been demonstrated in this thread, even those "crystal clear" use cases are often misunderstood by many (proprietary program linking to a GPL library comes to mind).

It helps a lot if the copyright holders clarify their own position, possibly in a license addendum. Like Torvalds did for the Linux kernel (regarding system calls). Now that didn't hinder the whole controversy of proprietary vs GPL kernel modules, of course.

The GPL is tricky.

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact