Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The focus on straws comes from two angles:

* the original environmental motivation was that they are strong, non-bio-degradable structures that pose threats to wildlife, similar to how the old 'can rings' got phased out.

* anything that involves government regulation, especially government regulation of stuff that involves the fossil petrochemical industry has an immensely well funded push back against it. It's a slippery slope, once you ban straws the next thing you know you might actually deal with the main cause of climate change and we wouldn't want that now would we.

> Their prohibition would, it was thought, reduce plastic waste getting into the environment. But to the degree that these bans led people to substitute paper for plastic, all they've done is swap out some minimal amount of plastic consumption for increased PFAS pollution.

Hmm "minimal amount of plastic consumption" vs "increased PFAS pollution"? Why is one pollution and one consumption? Why is one "a minimal amount" and the other an "increase"?

It's because this is effectively a PR outlet for fossil fuel corporations.



>>>once you ban straws the next thing you know you might actually deal with the main cause of climate change and we wouldn't want that now would we.

How are you going to deal with solar radiation, earth's position and orientation, the jet stream, and water vapor?


Can you cite a source that suggests those 5 things combined are a bigger impact than the real actual accepted by science singular main cause? I'm prepared to let it slide that you've named 5 different things as I think you're still factually incorrect even if I let you clump them together.


This is a joke, right? You're saying the sun, the Milankovitch cycle, water vapor, and other natural processes have less of an impact on climate than humanity? Care to explain how? That's hilarious. LMAO!!!!

The sun puts 4.4 x 1016 watts into Earth each year. How much does humanity put?


You appear to have misread the part of my comment that you quoted. I said:

> the main cause of climate change

You for some reason thought I was talking about the "main cause of climate". What an odd misreading.

But at least you're not making wildly inaccurate claims about climate change, just missing the point. You do believe in the accepted scientific consensus on climate change right? Now that we've established we're talking about climate change, and not just the climate.


The only system that causes climate change is the sun-earth-water heat dynamic. Everything else is just religious bleating and used-car salesmanship.


OK.

For those interested in reality:

https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/weather/climate-change/causes-o...

Covers the contribution of these natural variations to climate change.

> Natural climate cycles can change the temperature of Earth, but the changes we are seeing are happening at a scale and speed that natural cycles cannot explain. These cycles affect the global temperature for years, or sometimes just months, not the 100 years that we have observed. Meanwhile, longer-term changes like Milankovitch cycles and solar irradiance take thousands and thousands of years.


The parent has a point that if these natural cycles change even slightly, however unlikely that may be, it will swamp out any effect humanity has made up til 2023, heck maybe even 10x everything humans have done.


Yes and if the sun blinks out tomorrow that will be the biggest effect of all. Remind me again why that is worth talking about, other than to distract and detract from a discussion of climate change?


This seems like a strawman, the sun blinking out is not a slight change, obviously if only a world shattering change could produce such a effect then there would be a different calculation. In the context of the natural systems the parent's comment refers to, even a 1% deviation is enough to swamp out all human effects combined.

And that is entirely within the realm of possibility.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: