Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Is Signal App Killing My iPhone Battery? (notes.ghed.in)
4 points by rpgbr on July 25, 2023 | hide | past | favorite | 5 comments



On iPhone, to truly disable an app from running in the background you must do BOTH of these things:

  1. disable "background app refresh"
  2. disable *all* notifications for this app
On IOS, enabling notifications is a "back door" that allows an app to run all kinds of battery and privacy sucking telemetry even when the app is "closed". The useless option to disable "background app refresh" is an (unintentional?) dark pattern that makes you think it does what both of these things together actually do. I'm assuming that some app makers are just abusing Apple's intentions with these settings.

Disable both of those for popular social media apps and watch as your mental health and battery life improve dramatically.

Of course with some apps (like messaging apps) you may actually want/need notifications so it's not always an easy choice.


This makes a lot of sense! I’ll try that.


Quite possibly. It does a lot of stuff in the background, maintains a large database (mine is ~3.5gb), and though you can back up the database, the app brilliantly won't let you decide where - so if you're running out of storage page and want to add an SD card, Signal won't let you store your backup there. I've gone from being an evangelist for it for several years to hating it, because the people who work on it seem to have little interest in their users and just want to play with feature toys.


I’m in the same boat: convinced my family to install Signal and now going through this headache. I hope they fix this issue.


This is the behavior of a spying app, bypasses the OS/kernel to hide its activity

Either that or a bug in iOS, either way it's fishy indeed




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: