1864 days ago
Fields medalist Tim Gowers: Elsevier — my part in ...
That's the main problem I see, really: buy-in from high-profile institutions. If a decent number of them started to publicize that they see papers published with New-Uber-Journal-System.XYZ as "preferred" over traditional papers, then people would queue up to publish there, and would force others to follow suit or be seen as "2nd rate". To do that though, NUJS better be have a bombproof method to produce quality reviewing (high-profile reviewers, a system of incentives targeted on quality not quantity etc etc).
1863 days ago
You can do that
in smallish areas through "journal revolts", which have happened a few times, where the senior people of the field all band together to endorse/run a new open-access journal, and basically say, "as far as we're concerned, this is now the top place to publish". For example, when nearly all the senior editors of the journal
resigned to form the open-access
Journal of Machine Learning Research
), that also sent a pretty direct signal that JMLR was the new place to publish, at least in these senior researchers' opinion.
Apply to YC