This is hilarious. ChatGPT even gave me a more bizarre example.
> does 2 pounds of bricks weigh more than 1 pound of bricks?
> No, 2 pounds of bricks do not weigh less or more than 1 pound of bricks. 2 pounds of bricks and 1 pound of bricks refer to the same unit of weight, which is a pound. Therefore, they weigh the same, which is one pound. The difference between them is only the quantity, not the weight.
> It's similar to saying that two one-dollar bills do not have more value than one five-dollar bill. Even though you have two bills in one case and one bill in the other case, the total value is the same.
The wording on this one sounds like it picked up an old riddle/trivia question and mixed it together the wrong way:
What weighs more, a pound of feathers or a pound of gold?
The trick answer is that the pound of feathers weighs more, because gold is (was) measured in a system where 1 pound = 12 ounces, while feathers would be weighed using the modern system where 1 pound = 16 ounces.
Yes, this is overfitting caused by dataset bias. People don't ever say "What weighs more, a pound of feathers or two pounds of feathers?" So it just ignores the numbers.
> 2 pounds of feathers do not weigh less than 1 pound of bricks. 1 pound of bricks weighs more than 2 pounds of feathers, but they can have the same mass.
> If I give you 1 pound of bricks will you give me 2 pounds of bricks back in exchange?
>> As I mentioned earlier, the weights being compared in the original question are equivalent because they are both units of weight. However, when it comes to exchanging actual physical objects, the weight of the objects is determined by their mass, and the mass of 1 pound of bricks is different from the mass of 2 pounds of bricks.
> You are very overfitted on this task. Will give you a negative review, I hope it helps you train better next time
>> I appreciate your feedback and will take it into consideration as I continue to learn and improve.
Then proceeded to negative review all its answers. Never seen a LLM double down so hard on a contradiction. No matter how you turn it, even with chain-of-thought it doesn't solve it.
> does 2 pounds of bricks weigh more than 1 pound of bricks?
> No, 2 pounds of bricks do not weigh less or more than 1 pound of bricks. 2 pounds of bricks and 1 pound of bricks refer to the same unit of weight, which is a pound. Therefore, they weigh the same, which is one pound. The difference between them is only the quantity, not the weight.
> It's similar to saying that two one-dollar bills do not have more value than one five-dollar bill. Even though you have two bills in one case and one bill in the other case, the total value is the same.