Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

How the story about your friend doing something (supposedly) illegal leads to conclusion that "all the arguments for their legality are largely moot"?

Especially after you tell in the very first sentence of your comment to leave arguments about legality aside.

Is this how you propose to judge the legality of a service?

            Can overcome technological restrictions
            to save music into a file instead of letting
            the browser download and play it immediately?
                |                            |
                |                            |
               Yes                           No
                |                            |
                |                            |
            Is the resulting MP3 ---- No ----+---> Legal   
            of high quality? 
                +--------------------------------> Illegal!

Try not to be so literal. My implication was that any service that lets a user download copyrighted material for free is bound to be terminated by the labels, and that is largely what is happening.

As opposed to just listen to copyrighted material [for which they have no license to distribute]?

No, that too, but the downloading makes the hammer come down heavier.

FWIW, Pandora is just as vulnerable.

I'm pretty sure he actually meant to put all arguments about legality aside. Any service, no matter how legal, that enables you to easily download high quality label music, no matter how illegal that process is, will be intolerable.

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact