Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

How to draw a circle (HAKMEM 149 through HAKMEM 152) reproduced below.

ITEM 149 (Minsky): CIRCLE ALGORITHM Here is an elegant way to draw almost circles on a point-plotting display:

NEW X = OLD X - epsilon * OLD Y NEW Y = OLD Y + epsilon * NEW(!) X

This makes a very round ellipse centered at the origin with its size determined by the initial point. epsilon determines the angular velocity of the circulating point, and slightly affects the eccentricity. If epsilon is a power of 2, then we don't even need multiplication, let alone square roots, sines, and cosines! The "circle" will be perfectly stable because the points soon become periodic.

The circle algorithm was invented by mistake when I tried to save one register in a display hack! Ben Gurley had an amazing display hack using only about six or seven instructions, and it was a great wonder. But it was basically line-oriented. It occurred to me that it would be exciting to have curves, and I was trying to get a curve display hack with minimal instructions.

ITEM 150 (Schroeppel): PROBLEM: Although the reason for the circle algorithm's stability is unclear, what is the number of distinct sets of radii? (Note: algorithm is invertible, so all points have predecessors.)

ITEM 151 (Gosper): Separating X from Y in the above recurrence,

X(N+1) = (2 - epsilon^2) * X(N) - X(N-1) Y(N+1) = (2 - epsilon) * Y(N) - Y(N-1).

These are just the Chebychev recurrence with cos theta (the angular increment) = 1-epsilon^2/2. Thus X(N) and Y(N) are expressible in the form R cos(N theta + phi). The phi's and R for X(N) and Y(N) can be found from N=0,1. The phi's will differ by less than pi/2 so that the curve is not really a circle. The algorithm is useful nevertheless, because it needs no sine or square root function, even to get started.

X(N) and Y(N) are also expressible in closed form in the algebra of ordered pairs described under linear recurrences, but they lack the remarkable numerical stability of the "simultaneous" form of the recurrence.

ITEM 152 (Salamin): With exact arithmetic, the circle algorithm is stable iff |epsilon| < 2. In this case, all points lie on the ellipse

X^2 - epsilon X Y + Y^2 = constant,

where the constant is determined by the initial point. This ellipse has its major axis at 45 degrees (if epsilon > 0) or 135 degrees (if epsilon < 0) and has eccentricity

sqrt(epsilon/(1 + epsilon/2)).

For the full MIT HAKMEM (a report everyone who programs should read at some point) http://www.inwap.com/pdp10/hbaker/hakmem/hacks.html

Looks like this would be awesome but I can't seem to get it to work (ITEM 149)...I tried for lots of different values of epsilon. Maybe I'm misunderstanding what a point-plotting display is?


EDIT: err - nevermind, I had a silly bug that didnt update the old values. Kinda working now!


I just took your 6th revision and started playing around with the parameters, and it's interesting how much variation you can get with simple manipulation: http://jsbin.com/umurar/11/edit

Your code doesn't work because x and y values don't change ever. Try adding

    oldX = x; oldY = y;

after "p=parseInt ..." and surprise, it'll draw circles :)

Applications are open for YC Summer 2018

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact