Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

And I think it's all bathwater. No more political parties. No more Coke/Pepsi choices of elected officials. No more outright corruption.

Open government, e-democracy. The time has come.




You're a bit of a techno-utopian. In small groups with homogenous polities and aligned interests, this might work. In an opensource project, for instance.

But even those fall into strife. Politics is part of human nature; the encrustations of western civilisation and elsewhere are not arbitrary.


You're a bit of a techno-utopian.

Maybe. But I think if you look at history, distributing power has always been the most successful strategies. Unfortunately, it's also the least popular with those who currently hold power, so it's often a knife fight.

I'm not quite sure it's as radical as you seem to think it is. Is voting for a Michelle Bachmann to vote on laws, or just voting directly on those laws, so different? Really? I'm not so sure. The internet has transformed every other industry. Can we not apply it to politics and leverage its power there?

homogenous politics

I've been arguing the U.S. perspective, and it is so divisive there that I don't think it could be worse.

Jacques, this will be my last post so: thanks for the great dialog. All the best.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: