Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Can you qualify why specifically you would prefer the old plan even though it is 'on paper' the same?



Not OP, but switching providers could mean one actually provides coverage and the other regularly denies it. I have upgraded health plans in the past, only to discover I spent more time fighting my insurance company because they just refused to honor the coverage. I actually had to get a lawyer involved at my own expense.

I find it bizarre how many people just trust that insurance companies will actually honor their contracts. In my experience, they likely won't. This is just my anecdote.


As a non-American, that sounds pretty fucked.


The American healthcare system is quite fucked. Proponents are typically profiting from it directly, have no idea what things are like in other places, or suffering Stockholm syndrome (and lack access to medical care to treat it).


It is not as bad as it sounds. There is an appeals process:

https://www.healthcare.gov/appeal-insurance-company-decision...

And in general, anything the insurance company might not want to pay for required a “prior authorization”, which usually happens if the insurance company’s doctors think there is another option for treatment or the proposed option does not have sufficient evidence.

I imagine there is similar processes in taxpayer funded healthcare systems too to properly allocate resources. Although, I am sure there are many cases of problems caused by insurance companies in the US, due to the bureaucracy.


It really is as bad as it sounds.

>I imagine there is similar processes in taxpayer funded healthcare systems too to properly allocate resources.

What the doctor orders is what you get. You can typically choose your doctor, as well as get a second opinion. The doctors are generally paid the same.


These are some pharmacists talking about prior authorizations for medicine, and they seem to exist in Canada, UK, AUS, and NZ.

https://www.reddit.com/r/pharmacy/comments/oekhrp/curious_ab...

I would be surprised if any country gave doctors blank checks for everything since no one has unlimited resources. There most likely is a system for figuring out where waste is happening and avoiding it.


Yes, but it's generally done on a national level. The waste in the American system is the requirement for an extra 73 rounds of paperwork for every interaction with the medical system.


I can't speak for all of Canada since health care is handled at he provincial level, but I think most provinces don't cover prescriptions except for the young and elderly, and even then prices are capped anyway.


What lotsofpulp and Judgmentality describe pretty much covers it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: