Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Side note: I don't get any audio in Firefox. I had to load the page in Chromium to hear audio.

This sounds like a feature rather than a bug. Website UI should not make sounds.




> This sounds like a feature rather than a bug. Website UI should not make sounds.

While I usually agree, the sounds that it does make are not intrusive. They're only in response to user events (page loading/loaded, something was clicked), aren't stupid-loud (IMO), are very brief, and don't include any spoken words. Think of hearing button feedback in sci-fi videos.

For what it's worth, I'm also using Firefox 79 and the sounds _do_ work after telling NoScript to enable Media from the site. They're loaded as MP3s.


> the sounds that it does make are not intrusive

That's quite arguably false.

> Think of hearing button feedback in sci-fi videos.

Most people are in fact not actually in sci-fi videos, and are often in situations where they would not want their device to start beeping and clicking.


> That's quite arguably false.

Arguably indeed. It's an opinion.

> Most people are in fact not actually in sci-fi videos, and are often in situations where they would not want their device to start beeping and clicking.

If my device started beeping and clicking when I don't want to, then I would mute the sounds. Browsers have a mute feature which allows me to mute the browser separately from other apps.

My device even has a physical mute button. If I don't want my device to start beeping and clicking then I would either not browse some random location I found on the internet (because random locations on the internet are well known for starting sounds) or I would use the device's physical mute button.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: