Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Looks interesting! Was Crux an easy choice? Did you consider any other databases (non-Datalog)? Or Datahike?



Crux was a pretty straightforward choice. Didn't really consider any non-datalog DBs. I've used Datomic quite a bit, but preferred crux since it's open source, has filesystem persistence and doesn't require a separate process for the transactor (nothing wrong with Datomic's choices; the tradeoffs just make it unsuitable for Biff). I went with crux over datahike since it's more mature and has postgres persistence (and Kafka persistence, not that I need that yet). I haven't actually used the bihemporality features of crux yet, but maybe they'll come in handy.


That makes sense to me. I've been trying to decide out of Crux or Datahike for a side project. I was leaning towards Datahike because I didn't like the idea of having to do a full document update like you do in Crux, but I need to dig into it a bit more.


Are you concerned about that for performance reasons or for ease-of-use reasons? To address the latter, I made a separate transaction format for Biff that allows merging (it's similar to Firebase's transaction format). So e.g.

  {[:users #uuid "some-user-uuid"] {:db/merge true
                                    :username "foo"}}

gets converted to

  [[:crux.tx/put (merge (crux/entity db #uuid "some-user-uuid")
                        {:username "foo"})]]

There is a race condition though; if another tx updated that document after the crux/entity call but before `:username "foo"` was written, then that tx would get clobbered. I'm planning to add `:crux.tx/match` operations automatically to prevent that from happening. There was talk on #crux in Clojurians slack today of using the newly-added transaction function feature to do merges. Haven't looked into that myself.


Just for ease-of-use. In Datomic/Datahike you can update a single datom/fact. I'll have to look into making some similar sort of helpers for what you've done.


https://opencrux.com/docs#_transaction_functions ``` (crux/submit-tx node [[:crux.tx/put {:crux.db/id :crux.fn/assoc :crux.db/fn '(fn [ctx eid k v] (let [db (crux.api/db ctx) entity (crux.api/entity db eid)] [[:crux.tx/put (assoc entity k v)]]))}]])

(crux/submit-tx [[:crux.tx/fn :crux.fn/assoc doc-id k v]]) ```




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: