Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Like English spelling has any rules. There are a lot of irregularities with English spelling that students need to learn by heart how the word is spelled compared to how it is pronounced.


English spelling absolutely has rules. The famous 'ghoti' example (where supposedly it should be able to be pronounced 'fish' because of 'gh' in rough, 'ti' in 'nation', etc.) is nonsense because there's only one way that word can be pronounced in English and that's 'goatee'.

Irregularities don't mean it doesn't have rules. The most common 1-2k words are much less regular than the rest of the language, but learning how they're spelt is not remotely difficult for children (no adult that doesn't have a learning disability struggles to remember how to spell 'much' or 'about'). The rest of the language is pretty much regular.


Funny, I always pronounced "ghoti" like "Gotti".


Slight difference in vowel, otherwise the same, that's valid enough. English isn't great at telling you the exact vowel, probably because people keep making them shift.


English is spoken with such a wide variety of accents that you can just about get away with using random vowels sounds and still be understood.


Obligatory "What if English were phonetically consistent":

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A8zWWp0akUU


English spelling has plenty of rules. It's just inconsistent and full of exceptions because English has its roots in many different languages and unfortunately inherits rules from all of them as well as having a bunch of its own.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: