Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Putin signs law making Russian apps mandatory on smartphones, computers (reuters.com)
24 points by talleyrand 3 days ago | hide | past | web | favorite | 5 comments

How do they enforce this?

I mean, can Microsoft, Google, and Apple reasonably just say "Uhh, no" and keep shipping products without these applications installed? Does that then put the burden on Russian retailers to open/tamper with the devices themselves before resale?

How can Russia reasonably force foreign manufacturers to comply with this? Are they in a position to say "No more importing Microsoft PC's!" Are they going to then require the use of a Russian linux distro? It would seem to me that our manufacturers are in the perfect position to band together and inform oppressive regimes that it's time to either design their own prison-stack or stop placing demands on companies based in free, democratic nations.

What if I am a Russian linux user? Will the government come to my house and inspect my system to ensure it is running the required level of spyware?

One way to enforce this is through sanctions, or limits placed on what can be brought into a country.

Usually hardware makers like Google and Apple have different sets of software (and hardware) for the different regions they sell to.

For example, why include a GLONASS chip if your users are in China, where BDS is the GPS system of choice?




...it’d be pretty easy for them to enforce this with Windows and Android, it’s not like Dell or Lenovo are huge in Russia? The hardware manufacturers are installing the applications, not the OS provider.

Additionally, OEM’s already ship custom versions of Windows computers for the EU so, what’s the difference?


had to bring this comment back from the dead. more context on SORM: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SORM

> SORM (Russian: Система оперативно-разыскных мероприятий, lit. 'System for Operative Investigative Activities') is the technical specification for lawful interception interfaces of telecommunications and telephone networks operating in Russia. The current form of the specification enables the targeted surveillance of both telephone and Internet communications. Initially implemented in 1995 to allow access to surveillance data for the FSB, in subsequent years the access has been widened to other law enforcement agencies."

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact