Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> I wonder how this will be applied in reality. Will individuals stopped have to wait for the police to ask before readying their documentation without being cited in addition to whatever they were stopped for?

That's what they've been telling people, yes. Honestly, it seems rather over the top legalism.

I understand the point about the danger of using mobile devices while driving a moving vehicle. But, what exactly is the danger of using one when you are stationary, especially if you have been pulled over by a police officer? It is a law without a rational justification, and laws lacking rational justification are harmful.




"Honestly, it seems rather over the top legalism." In Australia? I can hardly believe it /sarc


I would guess it's to eliminate a loophole of 'No Officer I wasn't checking Snapchat, I was just getting my digital licence out for you.'


> I understand the point about the danger of using mobile devices while driving a moving vehicle. But, what exact is the danger of using one when you are stationary, especially if you have been pulled over by a police officer? It is a law without a rational justification, and laws lacking rational justification are harmful.

This is the core of the issue, in my opinion.


The danger is loss of police revenue. In Australia it’s illegal to use your phone to pay at a McDonald’s drive through if your the one sitting in the drivers seat. Even if the car is in park.


Got a reference for that? Road rules typically apply to... roads, not private property.





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: