Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

So I worked on this project. As with many stories this one has been simplified to be less boring and emphasize key points. I generally agree with Guillaume’s characterization—he’s a brilliant engineer and it was great to work with him.

The most important advantage of Go was that it is statically typed and there was a broad agreement that we should use a typed language to prevent errors. The other advantage was that Go is faster than Python, allowing us to move logic out of the C codebase and unify the high-level operations in a single codebase. The other other advantage of Go was that it is not C++, for which we were all grateful. As with most real projects, the rewrite occurred concurrently with adding features and tightening coding standards — `go fmt` was a big motivator and the Go codebase had much more comprehensive test coverage than the Python one.

>Also, for a sense of scale, this rewrite took about 4 years to complete from first concepts.

That’s not quite accurate. In fact the Python production code was largely ported by mid-2015, and the Go library was feature-complete by 2016, albeit still linking to C. However, there was a lot of non-production prototype code, implementing more complex optimizations and written in a few additional languages, which took another two years to port, and also to be made production-ready. Perhaps what’s important is that we were able to keep adding new improvements while still “porting” this code. (Real life is a poor laboratory.)

>effectively never updated the library.

It is, or was, still maintained. Most of the very low level file operations had been optimized to death already. Higher-level functionality was slowly moved out of the C library. I left Salesforce in 2017 so I’m not sure what happened next. (Incidentally I left not only Salesforce but tech entirely - I’m now at grad school for medical physics.)

>I imagine it is easier these days to find Go devs than C devs

Maybe? None of us knew Go when the porting began. I think if you know at least 2 programming languages and one of those is C-like, Go will be a piece of cake. I was hired with no Go experience and ramped up quickly.




Thanks for the detailed reply! Getting a real perspective instead of an article is always great.




Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: