Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Scottish judges rule Parliament suspension is unlawful (bbc.com)
22 points by tosh 12 days ago | hide | past | web | favorite | 5 comments





It will be interesting to see if, in the aftermath of all this, we end up with a more formally defined constitutional system, or if we'll just carry on as before.

I can't see us adopting a "big ideas" written constitution any time soon, but perhaps some of the structures may become more explicitly defined in legislation (in the way fundamental rights were enshrined in the Human Rights Act).


We can hope - or perhaps we should not.

Who would we trust to reform our famously short written constitution? Ten words or thereabouts that was the fudge after the restoration, to give parliament sovereignty.

I certainly wouldn't want the modern political parties defining or improving this, yet who else? We probably need to lose a major war, so the victors can "give" us a reforming and benign constitution, like was successfully done a time or two in Europe.


Absolutely. We can't even change our voting system, I can't see a written constitution being agreed any time soon.

This is the awkward truth: democracy can't be created democratically. It has to be imposed by a dictator.

It comes from chaos. It can be agreed though.

The US constitution came from the revolution, and attempted to correct some of the issues of the time, but without needing a dictator. Interesting that the US president gets a broadly similar role and powers to George III, just with restrictions on length of office. We've reformed all of those powers away, they kept their 18th century monarch, oops president, and added a few new powers. :)

The baby steps often come from localised chaos - riot, civil disobedience and such. Don't think we could push for a good constitution that way. We'd get a biased, subservient to the parties one. But we'd be told we got what was agitated for.




Applications are open for YC Winter 2020

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: