Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Lots of footage with clear faces, shouldn’t be very difficult to put names next to those.

Does anyone know of any co-ordinated efforts to do so?




https://reddit.com/r/hongkong has a lot of discussion and footage of these guys coordinating with the police, including them getting into vehicles with mainland license plates.


Is that really the right course of action, given the protests are a push back against China asserting control and surveillance over HK's citizens?


The protesters are being subjected to the assaults rather than being the masked assailants.

My gut reaction is these attackers are from mainland China and who have been organised by an official in order to try and reduce HK's tendency to protest (a sentiment echoed in that article as well).


What do you suggest? Should they just bend over and take it?


The protests are over a law allowing China to extradite people without any process.

Also government mass surveillance and identifying people who were recorded in public by a citizen commiting violence aren't the same thing. I wish I didn't have to explain this.


> The protests are over a law allowing China to extradite people without any process.

That is not true that there would not have been any process.

There would have been a full legal process like any extradition: I.e. extradition would have been requested based on a legal case, this would have been examined by a HK court with the 'accused' able to defend, then that HK court would have made a decision. [That's the actual bill]




Applications are open for YC Winter 2020

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: