On: A Kernel Engineer at Microsoft's Answer to “What Do You Think about ReactOS?”

[Veen]

What would he say other than what he has already said? The ReactOS devs are not addressing the substantive points. No point in him repeating himself.

[mapcars → Veen]

Em, for example how the book linked here several times is not documentation on kernel internals?

[axelriet → mapcars]

It’s not documentation no. Some smart people spent a lot of time observing and disassembling and explained a number of things but major aspects are entirely missing, and not all of what is written is accurate. In any case this definitely is not documentation, and certainly not enough information to write not only a compatible implementation, but a compatible implementation with very similar-looking source code.