Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Show HN: Map of Polish Composers (mapofcomposers.pl)
73 points by stared on May 9, 2019 | hide | past | favorite | 12 comments

Author here.

I did the D3.js part - the main graph and timeline. Force layout link strength was based on Pointwise Mutual Information, vide https://github.com/stared/tagoverflow.

I was given the data. There is an accompanying write-up: https://culture.pl/en/article/what-makes-a-composer-polish

Official project info:

"Map of Polish Composers is the most comprehensive resource ever dedicated to Polish music giving users instant access to biographies, extracts from recordings and a carefully charted map providing a rich global cultural context for every artist highlighting their influences and inspirations.

Map of Polish Composers is powered by Adam Mickiewicz Institute.

The project is created by the Adam Mickiewicz Institute as part of the Polska Music and POLSKA 100, the international cultural programme celebrating the centenary of Poland regaining independence.

Financed by the Ministry of Culture and National Heritage of the Republic of Poland as part of the multi-annual programme NIEPODLEGŁA 2017–2022."

The UI is not very intuitive:

- I clicked Karol Szymanowski and I didn't notice I can scroll to see the content - only after reading HN comment I figured out I missed something. There needs to be an arrow or text needs to be formatted differently.

- Breadcrumbs keeps appending even though I go back

- Players show you can skip part of the sample, but you can't

- Blocked right click :(

It's amazing. Not that I'm interested in Polish composers specifically. If you could find a way to generate these for different fields (mathematicians in specific domains, machine learning researchers, electronic musicians in different genres, DJs, etc whatever people are interested in), it would be awesome! You could have a set of websites for different topics (and, who knows, maybe make money from ads related to the topics).

I have a platform for that https://theymadethat.com/

The UI still needs work (especially for mobile) and there's a lot of missing data, but the platform itself is up and running.

It's essentially IMDB for everything. You can list people's work and see all the relationships i.e. is that part of other stuff? who used something as a tool? who else worked on it?


If there's something I can change or add - let me know

Seems very buggy due to handling of requests - some examples:

- if I'll search for "Zagajewski", then search for "Fryderyk", I still get "Zagajewski Artur" in results; what should happen is it should clear results on blur

- if I click Timeline, then Centers, then Timeline again all it does it makes the dots juggle; what should happen is there should be a loading bar indicating loading of resources and rendering

- there are requests to http://mapofcomposers.pl/wp-json/wp/v2/kompozytorzy?per_page... for no reason at all

- please clear the breadcrumbs at some point

Lacks 3 most successful Polish composers of last few years: Marcin Przybyłowicz, Mikołaj Stroiński, Adam Skorupa

They created music for many video games, including the Witcher series. Even got some awards for it in game media (https://www.ign.com/wikis/best-of-2015/Best_Original_Music for example).

I find it funny that film music is considered art by some cultural institutions , but video game music isn't.

On Firefox 60.6.3, when I click on a composer’s name and an article pops up, I am unable to scroll down in that article. Consequently, I can only view the first lines of any article. I am running uBlock Origin and NoScript, but I have enabled all scripts except Google Tag Manager and HotJar, and I don’t think those two scripts should be necessary for a site’s functionality. Anyone else experiencing the same?

Thanks for bringing it. Sadly, I have no control over the current form.

"We are in the process of updating our website. Please feel free to feedback on your browsing experience using the above email address. Thank you! PSTYCZYNSKA@IAM.PL"

Seems to start at the early 20th century, makes one curious why not earlier,to have space for Chopin?

Wow, this is fantastic! Is this open sourced, anywhere?

Sadly, not.

When playing a song I can't drag the time mark.

Applications are open for YC Summer 2023

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact