Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Canadian Cops Will Scan Social Media to Predict Who Could Go Missing (vice.com)
42 points by nwrk 6 months ago | hide | past | web | favorite | 15 comments

Right. Of course. "The children". It's amazing how "liberal" democracies use "the children" as an excuse to spy on everyone and to take everyone's rights away. At least the chinese or russians are honest about their authoritarianism.

And why stop at social media? Why not go all the way and just install cameras in people's home "to predict who could go missing"?

Canadians must feel warm inside knowing how much Big Brother loves them and wants to look after their children.

It was inevitable. We kept telling people to not give away their data like that, that centralizing that much power in the GAFAS is dangerous, that somebody will abuse it.

Few people listened, even fewer without labelling us as paranoid. Almost nobody cared.

The problem is not that there are bad actors. Any sufficiently big and complex social system will have them. We must live with them, it's part of reality, like gravity.

The problem is that the rest of the actors are not thinking a second about their life or actions. They don't build a society. They cruise through existence.

This will always lead to pain.

We do have a variety of problems with internet freedom in Canada, but it's not just children that the article mentions. It's about identifying high risk individuals in general. The article also talks about potential minority bias which is something worth considering—not as a justification for anything or with any particular implication, just worth thinking about—in that in certain areas indigenous young women are going missing and are often never found or are found dead and it's a tough problem. Hugely complicated though and you can't use any particular issue to justify mass surveillance because the consequences could be immense.

Reminds me the short story "All the Troubles of the World" by Isaac Asimov where a supercomputer could predict future crimes of any individual in the world.

Yeah... Right that's why they'll be doing it.

but think of the children

How does this even work?

If they post a lot then stop posting as often?

Talking about running away?

I know the younger generations have more of an online presence but I wonder what they have in their risk factors.

They just want to log everything, and they thought this was the reason that would sound most reasonable to the general population (hopefully they can blame AI for choosing this reason, because it is very poor).

That's really cynical, but I kind of believe it.

It looks like "predictive policing" is already an outsourced thing. www.predpol.com

Philip K. Dick was a visionary.

It was supposed to be a warning, not an guide book!

I will always support this sentiment.

Life imitates art: https://youtu.be/jdl6eAIx2K4

For your safety and protection, you now need to insert your recta-cam.

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact