Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This is insane given that the executive branch has been jiggering around with the withholding amounts for the entire year. Yes, you probably paid slightly less in tax during the year, but unless you were paying attention to your federal withholding, you're probably in for a shock with your federal return.



The solution to people’s inability to save is not for the government to hold their money hostage.


> The solution to people’s inability to save is not for the government to hold their money hostage.

Meanwhile, in the real world where the left-hand side of the Bell curve exists, and where many people have poor impulse control, that actually is the solution to some people's inability to save.

Heck, as a student I worked in a union shop where this was actually baked into the collective agreement because of past experience of people not being able to save.

It shouldn't necessarily be mandatory, and there are ways to adjust one's withholding taxes, but it isn't all-bad.


But wouldn't we all be more free, really, if we just gave everyone enough rope to hang themselves & then locked up the left-hand side of the bell curve in debtor's prison?


Does the left hand side of the bell curve actually owe any federal income tax?


FICA is always paid, and hits lower wages harder. You know that money just goes to the general fund.


Then make it a line item in the budget called basic income or savings something transparent, and give it to everyone.


It is, actually. Unless you have figured out some previously-unknown way to successfully educate the entire population to be financially responsible?


We do have public education but I suppose its too much to make this sort of thing mandatory.


Clearly that's not enough. Asserting that it should be and doing what amounts to punishing people because you don't like the way they are isn't going to help.


Except that is literally the solution, witness superannuation plans and social security systems around the world.


Not a big fan of those either, but at least give access to invest the funds in a savings account or the market. I’d rather we teach some basic finance and civic responsibility in school.


[flagged]


When you take the standard deduction on your return you are engaging in tax avoidance. When you invent a 3rd child that never existed you are engaging in tax evasion.


Also a problem.


Indeed. I always aim to get no refund or to owe. There is no good reason to give the government an interest-free loan with your own money.


Definitely agree. Like others have commented here, you should be trying to minimize your return as much as possible.

The point of the article was that people are waiting for their large refunds and are deferring health care until they get those refunds. My point is that many of those people won't actually be getting a return and won't be able to afford the health care that they need.


It is easy to ignore the reality of human nature especially for those who are struggling.


You can adjust your tax withholdings to reduce your refund. I personally aim to minimize my bill or refund.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: