Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> They've evolved a relatively simple and effective system for allowing users to make, share, and document libraries.

Well, as is often said, simple is not easy. :) There's a large effort by the CPAN testers community to run every module (and every new version of it) against a large array of hardware and operating systems[1], and provide automated reporting to the author of any problems.

This is possible because of (and incentivizes) the other great aspect of CPAN and the public modules which are on it, which is a strong culture of good test coverage of modules, and the CPAN clients running all tests and failing to install by default if any tests fail that weren't expected to. It's another wonderful feedback loop, and one not encouraged or discouraged by most languages specifically, so the fact that so many package managers for languages decided not to do so is unfortunate. When you don't start with that as an expectation, turning it on at a later date likely just results in a horrible user experience as a large number of module just fail to install (or at a minimum spew warnings which are confusing) because they are exposing what was previously something only the author saw most the time.

1: http://matrix.cpantesters.org/?dist=Path-Tiny+0.104




Thanks for the helpful replies. I didn't know that.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: