Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

When the article calls it "Visual Programming" then I'm the target. If they describe it as domain specific visual editor then you will have a point.



check back in a few weeks... we are working hard on the tools and you should be able to try it yourself.

I definitely want a good demo video on the page.

but listen, I get it, I tried literally 50 different such tools, they all suck. Nobody in their sane mind decides to write one if you don't have a good reason. Certainly not in Idris :-)

but we have good reasons:

1) compositional theories of diagrams exists 2) such diagrams can express many "topologically equivalent" expression in the same diagram, this is a huge win! and very different from (AFAIK) all existing node-based editors 3) use cases in decentralised computing require fault-free tools that work like this

but really, I think generally applicable usable 2d-syntax exists...


I think most people here disagree with general applicability but if you had simply sold it for your specific use-case/domain you'd probably have much more positive responses.


I also disagree with general applicability :-)

But fair enough, I hear this a lot.

OTOH, a side-effect of working categorically is that we really assume very little, so we can apply the system is many things (at least the core doesn't restrict us, of course you still need to write code etc).

this is unlike all other systems which are domain specific.

you should think of it much more like an alternative syntax for bits of constrained Haskell code... anyway, thnx for the feedback, I am mainly surprised to see this on HN =)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: