Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Intentional Acoustic Interference Damages Availability and Integrity in HDDs [pdf] (umich.edu)
30 points by weirdo1 10 months ago | hide | past | web | favorite | 12 comments

Only on Hacker News the first comment is the best comment. Long life Brendan Gregg, the guest star of the above video and our beloved Linux Performance guru!

I recently had a problem where a hard drive was being negatively impacted by the noise caused by cooling fans in the chassis.

The hard drive was a Toshiba P300 3TB model HDWD130XZSTA. In the last year or two, since Toshiba's corporate troubles have gone on, they have started to price their hard drives more competitively. They seem like pretty nice drives in regards to performance and noise, but I discovered that this model at least seems to be susceptible to errors when subjected to nearby acoustic noise/vibration.

The server was a generic 1U with six 40mm fans in the center behind the hard drives. When the fans run at full speed they are really loud -- like seriously hurting your ears loud.

I first noticed something was wrong when some SMART errors developed on one of the drives, indicating a failure. I RMAed that drive and then got a new one, but the linux mdadm RAID rebuild was insanely slow. Further tests showed that the new drive was performing terribly and I went through the process of troubleshooting.

It took awhile before I finally figured out it was the fan noise causing it, but you could really see the transfer speed ramp up/down when I plugged the fans in/out. When the fans running at full speed, the drive read rate (hdparm -h) would drop down to 1MBps or even less, whereas they would go up to 175-190MBps normally. The read errors were SO bad that it must have triggered a SMART failure on the previous drive.

I've been a sysadmin for about 20 years now in datacenter environments and this was the first time I've seen an effect this substantial.

It's noteworthy that this same chassis has two Seagate drives in it which didn't suffer any negative performance issues from the noise.

I guess that's what I get for using desktop class drives in a server.

Are you sure it was acoustic noise?

I don't know how fans actually implement variable speed. But I can think of several methods that would generate lots of electrical noise. Fan manufacturers have an incentive to build as cheaply as possible, so I doubt they take too many steps to mitigate crap they put out on the power lines and/or radiate from their speed controller.

Well, like you said, you don't even know how fans work.

Fans implement variable speed through PWM which is a square wave and therefore rather noisy.

For what it's worth Western Digital does extensive testing of drive performance under audio vibration, especially on mobile drives that are likely right next to a laptop speaker.

And if you check page 7 of the PDF there is a small table that indicates that this has to be at around 120dB to have an effect. I do believe that is up around the point where you risk physical pain and instant hearing loss.

Bad news for UBeam then.

Well they came across as a pipe dream from day one...

Can you cite a source or provide a little more info on how you know this? I'm interested in this kind of thing. See my story above about a recent problem I had with a Toshiba drive.

ugh, that 24h edelweiss test is forever burned into my memory :-/

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact