Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

This seems strangely off-topic if you're not going to at least vaguely discuss the specific point. And on this specific point, it looks quite strange to be feeling superior as a European. Is Europe better when it comes to asymmetric surveillance, i.e. the government increasingly videotaping everyone but not allowing anyone to videotape them? That isn't the case as far as I know: many European countries have extensive CCTV surveillance systems on the one hand, but broad, restrictive laws about filming "sensitive" government activities on the other hand.

For example, in the UK, there's a CCTV on every corner, but photographing the police can get you up to 10 years in jail (http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29225389/) and harassment of photographers is common (http://youve-been-cromwelled.org/?p=1079 , http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2009/apr/16/police-delete-touri...). It seems Germany harasses photographers as well (http://www.toytowngermany.com/lofi/index.php/t3168.html).

I'm not a fan of the direction the US is going on this issue, either, but I don't think this is a case where Europe is doing better. On health-care and social safety nets, yes, but not on civil liberties, which was the subject at hand.




As far as I'm aware, from following the photographers versus police issue as a non-photographer, and critically, from far outside of London, the advice from the Chief Police Officers to their own staff has been that you can't arrest people JUST for taking pictures, except in very specific circumstances and that taking pictures by itself doesn't count as suspicious behaviour.

The problem is that the police on the ground have been whipped up into an anti-terror frenzy - and are largely thugs in any case - and there's a disturbing number of them just ignoring these instructions.

After the lack of prosecution over Ian Tomlinson's death, there's a strong feeling in the country that Something Needs To Be Done about the police. It's fine for them to club annoying hippies protesting about something or other, but the 'ordinary' people are starting to feel worried now and that won't end well.


Europe is not Britain and vice versa.

As a non-European, based strictly on coverage I've seen as part of the photographic community, it seems that Britain's surveillance-happy tendencies are not nearly so strongly replicated through the rest of Europe.

The freedom situation in Britain has gotten so bad that I'm not sure that Brits have a leg to stand on when criticizing the US for its increasing lack of freedoms, the over-reaching arms of the law.

That being said, Americans have nothing to be proud of when it comes to these sorts of laws - they are a clear encroachment on your freedoms, and a clear example of the exact sort of power abuse that the Founding Fathers specifically forewarned of, and sought to prevent. It's so textbook as to be galling, yet the courts' support of them is just depressing.


German here. Tried to film the police arresting some guy near where I live, they immediately came over and asked me to delete the videos or else they would take my camera (cell phone)


It’s illegal for them to do that. You can tape whatever you want in public places. You might not be allowed to publish it depending on what exactly you are taping but just filming something is not prohibited.


>just filming something is not prohibited

In the UK if any action is causing distress to someone I think the police are allowed to stop you doing it (based on a naive reading). There are some pretty general laws on our statute books.


I guess we are lucky that the law in Germany doesn’t follow the the-camera-steals-your-soul-theory with regard to personal rights – i.e. taking a photo or filming in public is never (pretty much, the exception is stalking) illegal, personal rights of the photographed can only be violated by making the photos public (and the law has certain exceptions were making photos public is legal even without consent of all the photographed).

But it’s certainly true that the police can majorly inconvenience you. They can take your camera away and even though they have to give it back to you and are not allowed to delete anything that they can do that at all does suck. At least they cannot fine you or worse.

The most annoying thing is that many in the police seem to be unaware about the law. (They strangely never seem to have that problem when a law gives them more power.) They will lecture you on and on about personal rights even if those are irrelevant as long as you don’t plan to make the photos public. (And even if you, say, documented police brutality a newspaper could print the photo no problem, they would just have to pixelate faces.)


Maybe you are right, but it doesn't matter. If I had a spare camera lying around and enough resources to deal with the legal system, I would love to provoke them and see how far I can go. But I don't.


They can take away your camera (i.e. you better not stop them from taking away your camera – but they have to give you a receipt) but they are absolutely not allowed to delete or change anything without a conviction of some sort (and you definitely won’t get any conviction for taking photos in public, no matter what you take photos of – stalking is the only exception but that’s not the case here).

They might even not be allowed to look at your photos without a court order (since looking at your photos is a search – I’m not sure about that one).

They can only keep your camera around as long as they plan on using it as evidence – meaning that if there is no investigation or as soon as the investigation ends or after the court is finished with the case they have to give it back to you (unchanged if the court doesn’t rule otherwise – which it won’t).

The good news is that the police in Germany cannot make you pay a fine or get you into prison for taking photos of them. The bad news is that they can inconvenience you by temporarily taking away your camera. Which they can do but as soon as they delete so much as one photo you should defend yourself and sue.




Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: