Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I think it probably depends on the complexity of the code as well. I can't count the number of times my unit tests on projects I alone maintain have saved my ass from releasing some unwanted bug into production due to a change I did.

Especially, if the codebase evolves due to new end-user requirements being discovered along the lifetime of the project unit test on various corner cases can be a lifesaver.

I'm not a bad dev, honestly. The complexity of the code I have to maintain just overwhelms my working memory. And yes, without any silly patterning. Sometimes domain requirements alone are sufficiently complex to confound a person without additional safeguards.

Another level of complexity comes from functionality that is rational only to include form third party sources. The third party sources must be updated frequently (because the domain is complex and later versions usually are subjectively of higher quality). The unit tests are about the only thing that can tell me in timely manner if there was a braking change somewhere.

Yes, there is smoke testing later on, but I much prefer dealing with a few unit tests telling me they don't work rather than dealing with all the ruckus from bugs caught closer to the end user.




On projects I alone maintain I prefer to only unit test the primary API. That usually gives me the information I need to triangulate issues and I move too slowly otherwise.


My tests are generally against the module interface as well. Unit tests don't need to be atomic, as long as they run sufficiently fast. Sometimes there is no 'correct' output, I just need to pinpoint if some change affected the output and is that a problem or not.

Dogmatic unit testing is silly. Testing should focus on fixing in the critical end user constraints and covering as much of the functionality visible to the end user. So, I would not necessary focus on testing individual methods unless they are obviously tricky.

In a an organization where everybody can code anywhere I would enforce per method testing, though. Sometimes a succint and lucid unit test is the best possible documentation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: