Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Personally, I don't consider using a phone number as reasonable. Usernames should be allowed for those who don't have or don't want phones.

I dunno. It's hard.

If you allow user-generated usernames, what's to stop me signing up as Linus Torvalds or Hillary Clinton, and creating drama for the lulz?

Using the phone number as a unique and verifiable identifier seems like a pragmatic - if not perfect choice. By using the SMS confirmation it makes it much more difficult for me to impersonate Linus or Hilary - because I'd need to impersonate their phone number _and_ respond to an SMS sent to it. Not nation state secure, but better than nothing...

The other problem Moxie's trying to solve is the discoverability problem - which jwz _doesn't_ want solved (nor do people with abusive exes or other categories of users Signal if often very vocally advocated for "Use TOR. Use Signal. Use a VPN!!!"). Moxie wants to be able to calculate the intersection of your contact list with every other Signal user's contact list, so it can prompt you to let you know you can use Signal to communicate with them which you'd otherwise probaby no know. And as he says, to be most valuable, e2e encrypted messaging needs to become the default messaging channel under normal use, so it'll not need to be installed/setup/learned under stress when it's need becomes critical.

I think Signal's got the "soundbite message" of what they do very carefully crafted and it's very enticing, but by nature soundbite sized or elevator pitch sized message inevitably leave out the complexity of edge cases.

I'm 99.99% sure Moxie isn't lying about what we could all read in the sourcecode if we cared enough to spend the time reading it - all the people jwz is concerned about sending him Signal messages already had his phone number in their contact list so could have already been sending him text messages. Moxie's view is jwz is better off having all those people know they can _also_ contact him using e2e encrypted messaging as well. jwz doesn't agree, and doesn't think letting all those people know he has installed an encrypted messaging app is "privacy protecting". There's certainly merit in both points of view.

Registration is open for Startup School 2019. Classes start July 22nd.

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact