Sometimes it ask you to choose the biggest square, not only biggest/smallest questions. The challenge varies all the time.
For example, I can ask you to choose the biggest triangle out of some boxes, circles and stars, and the question sentence can be displayed using a line of traditional CAPTCHA
I can see where that'd help (significantly), but I don't see how a captcha-reader can't also parse the key words, and interpret the image appropriately. "size-est" and "shape" / "color" is easy to rip out, and a basic OCR to detect shapes and sizes and a number is pretty basic.
And remember that the site lists Captchas as being OCR-able, and that the question sentence must be readable - quickly - by humans, so it can only be weakly obfuscated, unlike some of the shorter Captchas. That weakens an already-claimed-as-weak system, so it's easy to assume the instructions can be read. Detecting a couple key words via a smallish dictionary seems simple at worst.
A few mistakes can be ignored, because the server must allow a few - people will make them too. After all of the above, what's the success rate on a dumb interpreter? Say, one that can't understand order of words, merely their existence.
I'm not seeking to totally shoot this down - I think it's an interesting idea, and with a large number of objects and some visual obfuscation could possibly supersede Captcha. But it's achieved by adding logical complexity; to retain ease of use, visual complexity / some other form has to be sacrificed, which makes it easier to read by machines. Or, potentially, making the image quite a bit bigger, so the images / objects used can be made significantly more complex ("click the dog" when given several images).
Infinite! Just this of the possibilities with that kind of system. You could keep adding different questions (just minor variations) and it won't be difficult to keep ahead of spammers. Plus there is always a trade off between security and ease of use. I think the ease of use with clickcha is well worth the slight loss of security.
I'll give them two guesses who will win most of the time.