Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

How many years off are we to truly conversational computer talk? The prompt 'pings' get in the way of the flow.

When will I be able to just talk to my computer and have it know I'm done and respond, with a 'ping' 'pong' system?

I don't even use my car's voice commands because it's really slow to use while driving. I would love to just say: "Hey text my wife I'll be home in 10 minutes" and have my car respond.




"Okay Google, text Marianne and say I'll be home in ten minutes". "Sending a message to Marianne, saying I'll be home in ten minutes. Send?" "Yes." "Sending."

I love Google voice assistant. My phone's mic is unusually bad though, so if you imagine all of the above with me learning forward and shouting at my phone... ;)


On the flip side it can be maddeningly stupid. I have two Tom's in my contacts. one is regularly texted and called and other very, very rarely so. When I try to use voice to text Tom, it asks me which one. Every time. This adds a lot of interaction and time and honestly makes using the phone touchscreen faster and more pleasant.

I have the Google Home and my kid loves the Ghostbusters song. For whatever reason if you ask Home to play Ghostbusters you need, first, to specify the song not the movie, even though I have no Netflix integration setup. Then when it gets it correct it will only play the instrumental version for some bizarre reason. Weird, its clear the Home engineers are Ghostbusters fans as you can ask Home "Who you gonna call" and it gives some humorous canned responses, but somehow they can't get playing the Ghostbusters song correct.

Worse, because I have Google Play Music, there's some kind of licensing limit with Home. If I have Home playing music then my desktop PC refuses to play any youtube content, not play music, but unrelated videos. I can't watch any youtube videos unless I log out. Its incredible how bad the usability here. Buying a device for your kitchen shouldn't make all your computers be unable to play videos.


My wife has 2 mobile phone numbers, one which I call every day (it's set as the contact default) and another which I only call occasionally when she's travelling internationally. Yet when I use "OK Google" voice to call or text her it asks me which number to use every time. Terrible user experience.


Have you thought of renaming the less-called one to Thomas? :D It's a bad solution, sure, but it is a solution...


That's what I ultimately did. I just named him Tom2 or somesuch.


Do you use a case with your phone? I've found a case that's ever so slightly too big causes the mic on my phone to be basically unusable, as any recording made with the case on is mostly covered by random pops from the phone sliding around by a tiny amount inside the case.


I do have a thick double-layer case on the phone, but it's a very snug fit.

I just called the Skype echo test service to have a listen to what my mic actually outputs. It's pretty bad! The sound is very muffled and almost inaudible unless I cup my hand over the mic and speak clearly. Removing the case doesn't seem to make any difference.

Sony Xperia Z5 Compact, if anybody's wondering which phone not to buy for regular phone calls :) I don't really mind too much as I only make phone calls once in a blue moon, but it would be nice to be able to use voice assistant more.


I have had several water proof phones, and that typically happens when the phone have gotten wet and then dried.

It seems that with a bit of bad luck, the mic can get clogged up if a drop of water ends up in it.

Try to hold the phone in running water so the mic gets wet, and then carefully blow out the remaining drop of water.


Ah! Good tip, I'll try that. Cheers :)


There will be refinements (eg, faster on-device speech recognition), but it's going to continue being a precarious construction of crude hacks until we have strong AI. Don't expect that any time soon.




Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: