Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

And there's my problem with how people kill GIF. It's never easy.

I right click on a Twitter 'GIF', I can't save it. I go to developer tools, they did a bunch of JavaScript fuckery just so I couldn't save it. Okay, I find a third party tool and save it anyway as a .mp4 file. Stupid.

I right click on an Imgur link, it saves a webpage. Okay, replace .gifv with .webm - oh, it redirects me to gifv. Last time I had to save something from Imgur, I had to use curl of all things to do it. It's ridiculous.

GIF is simple. You upload the file as an image, something everybody mastered doing, and it will play, no questions asked. Videos are hard. Everybody wants to re-encode them in different formats, everybody has to include a fancy player in an iframe. You have to check for browsers since you can't solely use mp4 because of patent whatever, and can't solely use webm because Apple hates Google that much.

GIF, the file format, is bad. 256 colors, file size, etc. But everything people are trying to replace it with is even worse.




Exactly. As the article says:

> If GIFs are like framed pictures you can take down and move to your new house, these GIF-like videos are murals painted right onto the wall.

In an ideal world, I would be able to bookmark a URL, refer to it 10 years later, and still get the exact same information. Unfortunately, this is not true for any of the image/video hosting services that we use on a daily basis, from Imgur to YouTube.

So if I really want to preserve a piece of information for later retrieval, I need to keep a copy on my own computer. I can right-click a GIF and save it as a file, and I'm pretty sure it will stay where I put it for the next 20 years (or more). I don't have the same kind of assurance with most other video formats. Yeah, the GIF is 20 times bigger, but who cares? Disk space is cheap. Bandwidth is cheap. Universal compatibility is hard.


Your examples are poor.

Twitter is a massive pile of JavaScript garbage - it's just as difficult to download a still image off it (I have a bookmarklet for the task).

On imgur I can just right-click on an animation and select "Download Video..." and I get the mp4. Just as simple as images.


Could you share the Twitter bookmarklet with us please? It sounds very useful.


It's very simple:

   javascript:location.href=$('.media-image')%5B0%5D.src
This navigates to the picture currently in the lightbox (so you might have to click on it in the tweet to zoom it)


With Firefox you can just press Ctrl+I and find the video in the media tab. No need for Add-ons or external tools.




Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: