Hacker Newsnew | comments | ask | jobs | submitlogin
jonknee 1506 days ago | link | parent

When was the last time Apple offensively sued for IP?

bitwize 1506 days ago | link

The last high-profile case was the aforementioned Apple v. Microsoft from 1988.

They've issued plenty of C&D letters and takedown notices to individuals making Aqua-alike UI themes for other operating systems, as well. Not nearly the same threat display as an actual suit, but indicative of Apple being proactive about IP defense.


nailer 1506 days ago | link

Indeed. It always struck me as odd they didn't C & D Microsoft for the aqua start menu in Vista and XP.


zefhous 1506 days ago | link

Granted, I don't think these have been used offensively, but here are two patents that they benefit greatly from.

Menu bar - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Menu_bar#Ease_of_use

iPod click wheel - http://www.ilounge.com/index.php/news/comments/apple-receive...

I have no doubt that they would protect these if other companies infringed upon them. They offer significant usability advantages that Apple doesn't want others to have.

What we're seeing now is a bit different. The market is moving so quickly now that Apple is trying to setup some boundaries that they don't want others to touch. I don't think they really had to do this with these examples. I'm not saying any of this is right, I'm just not all that surprised by it happening.


cma 1505 days ago | link

The cited reference in the menu bar link is a design patent, which is very different from a regular patent. Anyone can implement a menu-bar system that lives at the top of the screen--it just can't look exactly like Apple's.


KT 1506 days ago | link

they were getting there with the QuickTime code, when MS settled that time for $150M... back in 97 or 96.


Lists | RSS | Bookmarklet | Guidelines | FAQ | DMCA | News News | Feature Requests | Bugs | Y Combinator | Apply | Library