Hacker News new | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Given that they found no relevant information on his work phone, exactly as experts and reasonable amateurs and common men predicted, how was it "worth it" as he claims? Is it that wasting huge sums of taxpayer money while attacking civil rights and attempting to instantiate a police surveillance state with no privacy is simply "worth it" no matter what, even if pointless?



It was worth it because they didn't know that beforehand. Now the FBI are sure that the attackers weren't in contact with other ISIS members. The FBI thinks that information is worth the $1.2M+ they paid.

How could they possibly have known that without unlocking the phone?


> Now the FBI are sure that the attackers weren't in contact with other ISIS members.

Umm, no - no they aren't. Not even close. The terrorists personal phones were destroyed before the FBI could recover them, this was just a 'work phone'.

Don't you think it's likely that a) there is a reason they destroyed their personal phones, and b) if they were going to communicate with other actors they'd be more likely to use the phone that's completely under their control?


Yes, you're right. I guess the FBI just confirmed that there was no info on the work phone, which seems a valid line of inquiry.


On the work phone, sure. Yay.

You do know that they destroyed their personal phones, right? And that it's been months now, wasted bickering with Apple even if there would have been any leads.

> How could they possibly have known that without unlocking the phone?

Smart money says they already unlocked it with an exploit and knew there was nothing, then played legal games with Apple until they started losing, and to exit gracefully they accepted the offer of one of the many firms begging to extract data from the phone for them.

They have the NSA's phone number. They were playing helpless for a reason.


Metadata?




Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: