Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It feels a little bit disingenuous to say that you can use a spreadsheet's builtin "sum" function to compute a sum. It honestly sounds like an argument in favor of functional languages; here's a Haskell program that's just as simple:

Prelude> sum [1, 2, 3] 6

Hey, you could even search for a library that sums lists for you in C, then include and call that function.




And in C++ you would write this as follows (with a range library it would be a one-liner):

  const auto & xs = {1, 2, 3};
  cout << accumulate(begin(xs), end(xs), 0);


Yes, it's a simple first order function on some kind of collection.

A sum function is not very `function' at all. (It sure feels at home in functional languages, more than in imperative bit-by-bit piecemeal programming, sure.)


I think the idea that the author was trying to express was that in a spreadsheet language, you select a data range and then choose a function to perform on that data. That's the "functional" aspect I took away from my reading of it.


Its no huge surprise that spreadsheets implement a form of FRP . Specifically, you can look at loeb's function [1] as an example of the relation. Being able to focus on the data itself while easily composing operations is definitely functional in nature.

However, FP is not a silver bullet either. In practice I think humans care a bit less about correctness than compilers and would like some aspects of the language to be 'fuzzy' for lack of a better word. To most people "1" and 1 are the same thing so why shouldn't the compiler understand that. There could be potential for a dynamic-fp language of sorts.

[1] http://blog.sigfpe.com/2006/11/from-l-theorem-to-spreadsheet...


`Fuzziness' and FRP are pretty orthogonal.

Ie even in Haskell as it is, it's pretty easy to add an 'if' that takes 'truthy ' and 'falsy' values like in Python. Just use a type-class 'Booly' that include a conversion function toBool.




Applications are open for YC Winter 2020

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: