Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Undeclared Martial Law on the Streets of Hong Kong (youtube.com)
50 points by tomcam on Oct 7, 2019 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments



“The police are attacking me now”

This journalist was not being accurate. There is a large difference between an attack and pressure. He claimed they wanted to clear the streets of cameras so that the police could do whatever they want. If everyone talked like that, nobody would trust the news. He exaggerated and speculated like crazy.

I’m assuming anyway he’s a journalist. Maybe he’s just a youtuber. Either way, don’t say “the police are completely out of control” when all they are doing is yelling aggressively and pushing a few people.


This 'journalist' is clearly biased for the protestors.


This guy doesn't know the basic definition of martial law.


That was very intense.

Anyone with knowledge of crowd control able to chime in about what it is the police are trying to do on a tactical level?


They don't seem either 'out of control' as he keeps saying or 'attacking [him] now' - as far as I can tell they're just segregating people into smaller groups on different sides of streets etc. so that they're more manageable for the comparatively small number of police.

It doesn't seem even to be about getting cameras away (which I would think wouldn't be surprising anyway) as he says towards the end - they actually seem quite unphased by that, other than keeping them a few feet away when they're questioning someone (it seems?) in the middle.

Just seems like a thrill or limelight seeking YouTuber not finding much of it, to be honest.


I have no such experience, but from the person talking it seems they are trying to get all the cameras out of an area so they can beat the crap out of those inside without being filmed.

It's classic authoritarian state intimidation tactics that they don't want recorded.


> so they can beat the crap out of those inside

Except this is speculation based on anti-China propoganda


There is clear video proof that they beat up the protestors, they just don't want more videos out there. It's not speculation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: