Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

>> "Source known only as John Doe says income inequality "one of the defining issues of our time" and calls on governments to address it."

Calling on any government to create change, not it citizens, is a mistake - especially on a topic like this.




That's a distinction without a difference considering that, in most democratic countries, the government is nothing but a segment of the overall population appointed as their legitimate representatives.

It is the government responsibility, in their mandate as representatives, to address the problems perceived as important by the citizens (as, for instance, the problem mentioned in the quote).

Now, if the government is unable or unwilling to use the power it was given "by the consent of the governed" to address such important issues then __that__ become "one of the defining issues of our time", not income inequality or any other problem derived from that.


> It is the government responsibility, in their mandate as representatives, to address the problems perceived as important by the citizens

But it is the citizens' responsibility to make clear to their representatives the problems they consider important. For a couple of examples of this principle in action, see the civil rights movement of the '60s, or the marriage equality movement of the noughts and teens. No politician would've dared approach those issues until the citizenry made its voice heard.

As a rule, on issues that we as peoples consider important, we lead our politicians, they do not lead us. This is partly because of the incentives in play in modern democracies and partly because, as you say, they are merely our representatives, not our dear leaders.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: